Brown and Caldwell Home Page
Technical Papers RECENT PAPERS    ALL PAPERS      LOG IN

Brown and Caldwell engineers and scientists are technical and thought leaders in the environmental sector. Meet the people who have been advancing innovation for more than 70 years.
Author      Title/Abstract      


A COMBINED USE ATTAINABILITY ANALYSIS AND TECHNOLOGY-BASED APPROACH TO SETTING ZINC STANDARDS FOR TMDL COMPLIANCE
Author: Bret Linenfelser
Date: 10/05
From WEFTEC Conference 2005

Historic mining activities at the London Fault Mine in Park County, Colorado, generate uncontrolled mine drainage which impacts water quality in South Mosquito Creek and Mosquito Creek. Water quality impacts have lead to 303(d) listing for both streams based on exceedances of chronic zinc table value water quality standards and the need for a total maximum daily load (TMDL). Historically, zinc concentrations in South Mosquito Creek zinc ranged from 110 g/L to 749 g/L and 95 g/L to 750 g/L in Mosquito Creek. The chronic zinc table value standards for South Mosquito Creek and Mosquito Creek are 250 g/L and 110 g/L, respectively. Historically, two mine adits at the London Fault Mine, the Extension Tunnel and the Water Tunnel, have had uncontrolled discharges of metals laden water to South Mosquito Creek which impacts the quality of Mosquito Creek, located downstream. Currently, only the Water Tunnel is permitted under the Colorado Discharge Permit System and the Extension Tunnel is un-regulated, but provides a zinc load to South Mosquito Creek five times greater than the Water Tunnel. Since multiple years of discharge permit negotiations for the Extension Tunnel have been unsuccessful, alternative approaches to regulate both discharges were investigated, including obtaining funding from the owner (THF Reality) of the water right at the Water Tunnel to support site-specific studies. Since limited funding was available from the owner of the London Fault Mine, Brown and Caldwell, through support from THF Reality, developed a multi-pronged approach to support appropriate South Mosquito Creek and Mosquito Creek beneficial uses while cost effectively allowing the Water Tunnel discharge to provide augmentation water for downstream water supply needs. The multi-pronged approach included: (1) evaluating treatment alternatives for both the Extension Tunnel and Water Tunnel to meet the proposed draft TMDL wasteload allocation for zinc; and (2) develop site-specific zinc water quality standards to reflect South Mosquito Creek and Mosquito Creek actual physical, chemical and biological conditions. Through the multi-pronged process a technology-based approach was developed and approved by the Colorado Water Quality Control Division and Commission. The technology-based approach focused on developing site-specific chronic zinc water quality standards using ambient (85th percentile) water quality as the standard, with treatment of the Extension Tunnel discharge. This approach provided substantial improvements to South Mosquito Creek and Mosquito Creek water quality, substantial cost savings by treating the Extension Tunnel discharge versus the Water Tunnel discharge and TMDL compliance.